Skip to main content

Table 4 Aggregate data individual study results for FEV1 at 12 weeks: difference in change from baseline

From: Efficacy of once-daily indacaterol 75 μg relative to alternative bronchodilators in COPD: A study level and a patient level network meta-analysis

 

PLBO

TIO 18

SAL 50

FOR 12

IND 300

IND 150

IND 75

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

FEV1

SGRQ

MOITA, 2008

diff

0

0

0.10

           

se

  

0.03

           

VERKINDRE, 2006

diff

0

0

0.11

−6.50

          

se

  

0.04

2.90

          

COVELLI, 2005

diff

0

0

0.18

           

se

  

0.04

           

CASABURI, 2000

diff

0

0

0.15

           

se

  

0.01

           

CASABURI, 2002

diff

0

0

0.13

           

se

  

0.02

           

NIEWOEHNER, 2005

diff

0

0

0.10

           

se

  

0.01

           

CHAN, 2007

diff

0

0

0.10

           

se

  

0.02

           

TONNEL, 2008

diff

0

0

 

−3.47

          

se

   

1.10

          

HANANIA, 2003

diff

0

0

  

0.10

         

se

    

0.03

         

MAHLER, 2002

diff

0

0

  

0.13

         

se

    

0.02

         

VAN RUTTEN, 1999

diff

0

0

   

−0.51

        

se

     

1.66

        

CELLI, 2003

diff

0

0

   

−2.10

        

se

     

1.28

        

GROSS, 2008

diff

0

0

    

0.08

−3.51

      

se

      

0.03

1.73

      

ROSSI, 2002

diff

0

0

    

0.04

       

se

      

0.02

       

DAHL, 2001

diff

0

0

     

−5.10

      

se

       

1.73

      

B2334, 2008;

diff

0

0

    

0.07

−3.20

0.17

−3.80

    

se

      

0.02

0.90

0.02

0.90

    

B2335S, 2008;

diff

0

0

0.14

−1.10

    

0.18

−2.50

0.18

−2.80

  

se

  

0.02

0.86

    

0.02

0.86

0.02

0.87

  

B2336, 2009

diff

0

0

  

0.11

−4.20

    

0.17

−6.30

  

se

    

0.02

1.01

    

0.02

0.99

  

B2346, 2008

diff

0

0

        

0.13

−4.75

  

se

          

0.02

1.22

  

B23354, 2010

diff

0

0

          

0.12

−3.80

se

            

0.02

1.21

B23355, 2010

diff

0

0

          

0.14

−3.60

se

            

0.02

1.40

BRIGGS, 2005

diff

  

0.02

 

0

         

se

  

0.02

           
  1. Diff = Difference versus comparator; NR = Not reported; se = standard error.