Author (Year) | Sex(male/female) | Age (Years) (mean,SD) (I/C) | Baseline chest radiograph Zones affected number(%)(I/C) | Baseline BMI (mean,SD) (I/C) | Baseline body weight (mean,SD) (I/C) | Baseline TB score (mean,SD) (I/C) | Baseline 25(OH)D (mean,SD) (nmol/L) (I/C) | Baseline calcium concentrations (mean,SD) (I/C) | Baseline CRP(mean,SD) (mg/L)(I/C) | Baseline ESR (mean,SD)(mm/h) (I/C) |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Daley 2015 [11] | 88/33(I) 101/25(C) | 41.6 (15.1)/43.7(14.3) | NM | 18.0(2.9)/17.8(3.0) | NM | NM | 63.1(46.6)/62.2(51.0) | 2.27(0.15)/2.28(0.17) | NM | NM |
Ganmaa 2016 [12] | 123/190(I) 133/200(C) | 31.0 (15.6)/35.0(16.3) | 7.4(4.4)/7.3(4.4) | 19.7(2.8)/20.1(3.1) | NM | NM | 7.8(11.8)/6.0(7.2) | 2.28(0.16)/2.26(0.18) | 62.7(46.1)/63.0(46.7) | 17.2(10.7)/15.8(11.3) |
Martineau 2011 [13] | 14/48(I) 14/50(C) | 30.7 (12.6)/30.5(10.1) | 2.8(1.3)/2.8(1.3) | 20.1(3.1)/20.2(2.7) | NM | NM | 21.1(20.0)/21.3(19.0) | 2.45(0.08)/2.45(0.09) | 71.4(49.5)/60.5(45.0) | 62.1(23.1)/60.9(17.4) |
Mily 2015 [14] | 36/36(I) 36/36(C) | 28.1 (9.9)/26.7(8.1) | NM | NM | 44.2(9.4)/43.7(7.4) | 7.9(5.6)/8.0(5.0) | 28.0(17.5)/28.1(16.2) | 8.82(0.55)/8.65(0.59) | 26.2(0.4)/32.1(0.4) | 54.0(31.1)/60.2(34.9) |
Nursyam 2006 [15] | 20/14(I) 19/14(C) | 29.9 (11.1)/32.6(11.6) | NM | 16.9(2.1)/17.7(2.5) | NM | NM | NM | 9.73(1.28)/9.4(0.92) | NM | 31.4(5.9)/36.7(6.1) |
Salahuddin 2013 [16] | 71/61(I) 70/57(C) | 27.8 (13.2)/28.3(14.1) | 3.6(1.4)/3.6(1.5) | 17.2(3.5)/17.3(4.0) | 45.2(7.6)/45.6(9.0) | 6.7(2.0)/6.9(2.5) | 20.6(8.5)/22.9(10.3) | NM | NM | NM |
Tukvadze 2015 [17] | 67/33(I) 60/39(C) | 34.1 (12.4)/32.4(10.6) | NM | NM | NM | NM | NM | 2.11(0.3)/2.17(0.29) | NM | NM |
Wejse 2009 [18] | 116/71(I) 106/72(C) | 37.0 (13.0)/38.0(14.0) | NM | 18.8(5.3)/18.5(3.8) | 51.9(9.4)/51.1(8.7) | 6.7(2.1)/6.8(2.0) | 77.5(23.8)/79.1(21.8) | 2.03(0.26)/2.03(0.24) | NM | NM |