Skip to main content

Table 5 Results of network meta-analysis of all-cause mortality

From: A comprehensive comparison of the safety and efficacy of drugs in the treatment of idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis: a network meta-analysis based on randomized controlled trials

Warfarin

           

2.51 (0.52,12.20) low2,4

Ambrisentan

          

2.79 (0.41,18.91) low2,4

1.11 (0.21,5.95) low2,4

N-acetylcysteine

         

4.73 (1.17,19.06)

low2,4

1.89 (0.66,5.36) low2,4

1.69 (0.38,7.58) moderate4

Bosentan

        

5.01 (0.84,29.68) low2,4

2.00 (0.44,9.15) low2,4

1.79 (0.28,11.55) moderate4

1.06 (0.28,3.98) moderate4

Macitentan

       

5.63 (1.54,20.55) moderate2

2.25 (0.91,5.57) moderate2

2.02 (0.49,8.24) high

1.19 (0.71,1.99) high

1.13 (0.33,3.82) high

Placebo

      

5.84 (1.44,23.61) low2,4

2.33 (0.82,6.65) low2,4

2.09 (0.47,9.39) low2,4

1.23 (0.59,2.58low2,4

1.17 (0.31,4.41) low2,4

1.04 (0.61,1.75) moderate2

Simtuzumab

     

7.18 (1.39,37.05) low2,4

2.86 (0.74,11.12) low2,4

2.57 (0.46,14.52) moderate4

1.52 (0.49,4.71) moderate4

1.43 (0.29,6.99) moderate4

1.27 (0.47,3.49) high

1.23 (0.39,3.83) low2,4

Imatinib

    

8.17 (2.10,31.82) low2,4

3.26 (1.20,8.85) low2,4

2.92 (0.67,12.69) moderate4

1.73 (0.89,3.35) moderate4

1.63 (0.45,5.93) moderate4

1.45 (0.96,2.20) high

1.40 (0.72,2.74) low2,4

1.14 (0.38,3.39) moderate4

Pirfenidone

   

8.38 (2.14,32.84) low2,4

3.34 (1.22,9.15) low2,4

3.00 (0.69,13.09) moderate4

1.77 (0.90,3.48) moderate4

1.67 (0.46,6.12) moderate4

1.49 (0.96,2.30) high

1.44 (0.73,2.84) low2,4

1.17 (0.39,3.50) moderate4

1.03 (0.56,1.88) moderate4

Nintedanib

  

11.26 (1.31,97.22) low2,4

4.49 (0.64,31.50) low2,4

4.03 (0.44,37.30) moderate4

2.38 (0.39,14.39) moderate4

2.25 (0.27,18.60) moderate4

2.00 (0.36,11.20) high

1.93 (0.32,11.69) low2,4

1.57 (0.21,11.55) moderate4

1.38 (0.23,8.12) moderate4

1.34 (0.23,7.95) moderate4

Sildenafil

 

11.26 (1.62,78.32) low2,4

4.49 (0.82,24.72) low2,4

4.03 (0.54,30.28) moderate4

2.38 (0.51,11.03) moderate4

2.25 (0.34,14.91) moderate4

2.00 (0.47,8.47) high

1.93 (0.42,8.97) low2,4

1.57 (0.27,9.13) moderate4

1.38 (0.31,6.20) moderate4

1.34 (0.30,6.07) moderate4

1.00 (0.11,9.47) moderate4

Pamrevlumab

  1. Data are OR(95%Cl)
  2. 1:Certainty lowered for imprecision
  3. 2:Certainty lowered for individual study risk of bias
  4. 3:Certainty lowered two levels for imprecision
  5. 4:Certainty lowered for indirectness
  6. GRADE Working Group grades of evidence – High quality: Further research is very unlikely to change our confidence in the estimate of effect; Moderate quality: Further research is likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and may change the estimate; Low quality: Further research is very likely to have an important impact on our confidence in the estimate of effect and is likely to change the estimate; Very low quality: We are very uncertain about the estimate