Peer Review reports
| Original Submission | ||
|---|---|---|
| 1 May 2018 | Submitted | Original manuscript |
| 4 May 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 2 | ||
| 4 May 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 2 |
| 14 Jun 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Jack Lowe |
| 16 Jul 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Charalambos Michaeloudes |
| 22 Aug 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 3 | ||
| 22 Aug 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 3 |
| 20 Sep 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Jack Lowe |
| 26 Sep 2018 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Charalambos Michaeloudes |
| 11 Dec 2018 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 4 | ||
| 11 Dec 2018 | Submitted | Manuscript version 4 |
| 25 Jan 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Charalambos Michaeloudes |
| 8 Feb 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Jack Lowe |
| 28 Aug 2019 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 5 | ||
| 28 Aug 2019 | Submitted | Manuscript version 5 |
| 12 Sep 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Reviewer 2 |
| 23 Sep 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Jack Lowe |
| 6 Nov 2019 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 6 | ||
| 6 Nov 2019 | Submitted | Manuscript version 6 |
| 11 Dec 2019 | Reviewed | Reviewer Report - Jack Lowe |
| 16 Dec 2019 | Author responded | Author comments - Jiawei Ma |
| Resubmission - Version 7 | ||
| 16 Dec 2019 | Submitted | Manuscript version 7 |
| Publishing | ||
| 19 Dec 2019 | Editorially accepted | |
| 21 Jan 2020 | Article published | 10.1186/s12890-019-1036-y |
You can find further information about peer review here.