Skip to main content

Peer Review reports

From: Joint association of cigarette smoking and PM2.5 with COPD among urban and rural adults in regional China

Original Submission
11 Dec 2020 Submitted Original manuscript
22 Dec 2020 Reviewed Reviewer Report
30 Dec 2020 Reviewed Reviewer Report - Bernardino Alcazar-Navarrete
26 Jan 2021 Author responded Author comments - Fei Xu
Resubmission - Version 2
26 Jan 2021 Submitted Manuscript version 2
31 Jan 2021 Author responded Author comments - Fei Xu
Resubmission - Version 3
31 Jan 2021 Submitted Manuscript version 3
13 Feb 2021 Reviewed Reviewer Report
14 Feb 2021 Reviewed Reviewer Report - Bernardino Alcazar-Navarrete
19 Feb 2021 Author responded Author comments - Fei Xu
Resubmission - Version 4
19 Feb 2021 Submitted Manuscript version 4
23 Feb 2021 Reviewed Reviewer Report
1 Mar 2021 Author responded Author comments - Fei Xu
Resubmission - Version 5
1 Mar 2021 Submitted Manuscript version 5
8 Mar 2021 Reviewed Reviewer Report
Resubmission - Version 6
Submitted Manuscript version 6
Publishing
10 Mar 2021 Editorially accepted
15 Mar 2021 Article published 10.1186/s12890-021-01465-y

You can find further information about peer review here.

Back to article page