Skip to main content

Table 1 Differences in the characteristics between the Stable and Deteriorated groups in the original cohort of the study and external validation cohort

From: Development and external validation of the DOAT and DOATS scores: simple decision support tools to identify disease progression among nonelderly patients with mild/moderate COVID-19

 

Original cohort

External validation cohort

 

All

Stable group

Deteriorated group

All

Stable group

Deteriorated group

n = 1675

n = 1531

n = 144

n = 324

n = 283

n = 41

Age, year

41 (25–53)

39 (24–52)

51 (41.25–59.75)***

42 (29.3–52)

41 (27–51)

51 (39.5–60.5)###

Male

919 (54.8%)

825 (53.9%)

94 (65.3%)***

181 (55.9%)

158 (55.8%)

23 (56.1%)a

Mild / Moderate-1

947/728

900/631

47/97 ***

260/64

240/43

20/21 ###

History of cigarette smoking

550 (38.0%)

479 (36.56%)

71 (52.59%)***

Temperature ≥ 37 °C

647 (40.4%)

549 (37.6%)

98 (68.5%)***

230 (71.0%)

195 (68.9%)

35 (85.4%)#

Temperature ≥ 38 °C

291 (17.8%)

219 (14.7%)

72 (50.7%)***

96 (29.6%)

73 (25.8%)

23 (56.1%)###

Diabetes or Obesity

175 (11.2%)

132 (9.26%)

43 (30.5%)***

53 (16.6%)

41 (14.7%)

12 (29.3%)#

Hypertension

197 (12.6%)

155 (10.87%)

42 (29.8%)***

Chronic respiratory diseases

75 (4.8%)

67 (4.7%)

8 (5.7%)

Malignancies

37 (2.4%)

31 (2.2%)

6 (4.3%)

Dyslipidemia

80 (5.1%)

68 (4.74%)

12 (8.51%)

Cardiac diseases

40 (2.5%)

33 (2.30%)

7 (4.96%)

Pregnancy

13 (0.8%)

13 (0.8%)

0 (0%)

MV and/or ECMO

7 (0.4%)

0 (0%)

7 (0.4%)

Deceased due to COVID-19

1 (0.06%)

0 (0%)

1 (0.06%)

SpO2, %

97 (97–98)

98 (97–98)

97 (96–97.75)***

97 (96–98)

97 (97–98)

97 (96–98)b

  1. ***: P < 0.0001 vs. Stable group (original cohort), ###: P < 0.0001 vs. Stable group (validation cohort), #: P < 0.05 vs. Stable group (validation cohort), a: P = 0.974 vs. Stable group (validation cohort), b: P = 0.055 vs. Stable group (validation cohort)
  2. In the original cohort, the numbers of missing data regarding “a history of cigarette smoking”, “temperature ≥ 37°C”, “temperature ≥ 38°C”, “diabetes or obesity”, “hypertension”, “chronic respiratory disease”, “malignancies”, “dyslipidemia”, “cardiac diseases”, and “SpO2” were 230, 73, 38, 108, 108, 99, 99, 99, 99, and 6, respectively
  3. In the external validation cohort, the numbers of missing data regarding “diabetes or obesity” was four
  4. Coronavirus disease 2019, COVID-19; extracorporeal membrane oxygenation, ECMO; mechanical ventilation, MV