Skip to main content

Table 1 Clinical and pathologic characteristics of patients and lesions in training and validation set

From: Factors associated with overdiagnosis of benign pulmonary nodules as malignancy: a retrospective cohort study

 

Training Set

 

Validation Set

 

Variable

Malignant nodules

Benign nodules

P Value

Malignant nodules

Benign nodules

P Value

No.of lesions

188

97

 

85

37

 

Median age (y)

53(46–59)

53(46–59)

.929

51(47–58)

51(46–55)

.690

Sex

  

.531

  

.624

 Male

59(31.4)

34(35.1)

 

35(41.2)

17(45.9)

 

 Female

129(68.6)

63(64.9)

 

50(58.8)

20(54.1)

 

Smoking history

  

.617

  

.039

 No

152(80.9)

76(78.4)

 

66(77.6)

22(59.5)

 

 Yes

36(19.1)

21(21.6)

 

19(22.4)

15(40.5)

 

Family history of cancer

  

.408

  

.126

 No

160(85.1)

86(88.7)

 

72(84.7)

35(94.6)

 

 Yes

28(14.9)

11(11.3)

 

13(15.3)

2(5.4)

 

Biomarker positivea

CEA positive(%)n = 300

24.3(34/140)

13.4(9/67)

.072

18.5(12/65)

17.9(5/28)

.945

NSE positive(%)n = 271

9.2(12/130)

11.5(7/61)

.629

3.4(2/58)

9.1(2/22)

.301

CYFRA21-1 positive(%)n = 297

25.4(35/138)

40.9(27/66)

.024

24.6(16/65)

28.6(8/28)

.689

SCC positive(%)n = 300

5.7(8/140)

4.5(3/67)

.711

6.2(4/65)

3.6(1/28)

.613

  1. Unless otherwise noted, variables are expressed as numbers of patients with percentages in parentheses, or as medians, with interquartile ranges in parentheses. CEA Carcinoma Embryonic Antigen, NSE Neuron Specific Enolase, CYFRA21-1 Cytokeratin 19 fragment, SCC Squamous Cell Carcinoma Antigen
  2. aData in parentheses are numerator/denominator; the number of patients for whom histopathological data were available for each molecular marker is given